5 Ways to Measure Recruitment Marketing ROI

By Nick. October 15, 2020.

Topics: Employer Branding, Recruitment Marketing

In previous blog entries, we’ve discussed in great detail some of the best practices for launching a recruitment marketing blog, the best practices for maintaining a recruitment marketing blog, how social media and other digital platforms can help enhance and further employer branding, and the value of content marketing in elevating your recruitment content strategy and how it moves the needle for companies in terms of finding the right people for their open positions.

Often times, the concepts and/or principles of recruitment marketing and employer branding frameworks not only makes sense on paper, but they sound extremely attractive to talent acquisition managers and specialists because they demonstrate to candidates an acumen with technology and current thought-leadership. But today’s recruitment teams are more than likely driven by one single word: Data.

Data tells a story, reporting drives action, and analytics push how recruitment teams deploy strategies or tactics in applicant sourcing. This means that proving return on investment when it comes to recruitment marketing and employer branding must not only be defined but clearly communicating for recruiters to understand the value proposition in continuing to engage job seekers in a marketing-driven way.

White Button with Web Traffic on Computer Keyboard. Internet Concept.

But what are the key metrics in recruitment marketing? How can today’s recruitment specialists understand ROI? What data points should recruitment teams look to as proof of concept? With these questions in mind, let’s examine 5 ways to measure ROI in recruitment marketing.

Time to hire

Perhaps paramount in a recruiter’s dashboard (perhaps overcome by one single metric that we’ll discuss in a moment) is time to hire, or time to accept depending on your industry and/or company’s verbiage. Regardless, we’re talking simply about the number of days that elapse from posting a job vacancy, engaging in recruitment strategy, and having a candidate accept an offer. In terms of a marketing funnel, think time to hire in the same realm as the buyer’s journey – the time from when a visitor to your blog or website became a lead, was nurtured, and then finally turned into a conversion via closing the deal of a sale.

It’s a simple question: Did a recruitment marketing strategy for a specific position in a specific market with a specific amount of resources allocated for the campaign result in a shorter time to hire than a similar position in a similar market without a recruitment marketing strategy?

That’s the question a recruitment specialist needs to answer to effectively evaluate whether recruitment marketing impacted the time to hire.

Cost per hire

As referenced above, the cost per hire is perhaps the only other metric that can dwarf time to hire, especially given the restraints, constrictions, and increased agility companies across the board have to face in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. The elements that factor into cost per hire can vary by industry, but essentially you’re looking at:

  • Promoting the position on job boards like Indeed
  • Utilizing outside search firms
  • Leveraging a temp agency to fill a position while a long-term candidate is found
  • Other methods of outreach and engagement such as posting a position to a professional organization or using a third-party to help funnel applications or mailing lists.

The costs of these avenues can range based on the depth at which recruiters deploy them. As with our time to hire example, it’s imperative to judge the ROI of recruitment marketing in an apples-to-apples fashion. You can’t judge how a recruitment marketing strategy fared with a highly-skilled position in a very competitive marketing compared with an entry-level position in a very feast-and-famine market.

If all things are equal and your cost per hire decreases when you execute a recruitment marketing strategy, then you have the ammunition you need in terms of proof of concept.

Social media engagement

While the first two ROI metrics relate directly to recruitment, the idea of analytics and reporting with regards to social media help prove directly how well your employer brand, narrative, and messaging are being received by job seekers as a whole – both the passive and active job seeker. The key data points are impressions (how many viewed your content), engagement (how many people liked, shared, commented on, or otherwise interacted with your content), and your amount of spend per boosted post or ad, particularly on sites like Facebook and Instagram, but also on platforms such as Twitter and LinkedIn.

In addition, when it comes to Twitter, another valuable metric is re-Tweets or how many times your Tweet was copied and Tweeted on another users profile. And, hey, if you can get your content trending (as long as it’s in a positive way) then you’re most likely golden in terms of reaching the maximum number of eyeballs with your employer branding.

But social media platforms like Facebook can also help evaluate how effective content is when it comes to recruitment. The number of link clicks on a certain post (particular if you drive traffic back to a specific job post or landing page) can also help you better understand the number of job seekers who not only engaged with your social content, but actually engaged with your job posting as well.

Web traffic

Very similar to the social media engagement metrics, evaluating your web traffic reporting relative to your company’s main website, individual landing pages, pillar pages, and other digital destinations is another KPI to consider when examining the strength, depth, and reach of your employer branding strategy. The same is of course true if part of your recruitment branding strategy includes a blog (how many hits, clicks on links in your blog post, and the amount of time visitors stay on individual posts), and these data points can also help drive editorial decisions in terms of the content you publish. If certain entries drive higher traffic rates than others, than your visitors are signaling the kind of content that matters most to them.

Part and parcel to web traffic analytics is video views either via your YouTube page or another third-party video housing service integrated with your website.

Brand awareness

What search terms are job seekers using to find you? Whether via a search engine like Google or a job board like Indeed, the closer and more specific job seekers are in searching you by brand and brand alone is a good indicator as to whether your employer brand via recruitment marketing is strong or needs some attention.

How large is your social media following? How many contacts do you have via email marketing campaigns? How many unique visitors do you have to your website as opposed to returning visitors? These metrics are critical in measuring ROI in both recruitment marketing and overall employer branding frameworks and strategies.

Get Your FREE Guide to Blogging eBook

Nick hails from Northern Illinois where he writes, runs, home brews, and spends time with his wife, daughter, and pug.


Find what you're looking for

Search our blog posts by keyword