How to Fail at SEO - It is Easier Than You Think

Photo of Jesse
Written ByJesse
Updated: May 14, 2026 Published: May 22, 2019
How to Fail at SEO - It is Easier Than You Think
6:53

TL;DR

What are the most common ways to fail at SEO and how can businesses avoid them?

Core Definition: SEO (Search Engine Optimization) is the ongoing practice of optimizing a website's content, structure, and keywords to improve its visibility on search engine results pages, establish topical authority, and drive organic traffic.

Despite constant algorithm updates and the rise of AI tools, SEO remains a vital component of digital marketing. However, many businesses neglect their search engine optimization or fall into outdated practices, leading to poor search visibility and lost traffic.

  • Avoid relying on the outdated 'one keyword per page' method; instead, optimize for long-tail, conversational phrases.
  • Consolidate and update duplicate content to prevent confusing search engines and annoying readers.
  • Treat SEO as an ongoing strategy rather than a one-time task by continuously updating pages and tactics.
  • Build topic clusters around pillar pages to establish topical authority and improve search rankings.
  • Perform regular SEO audits and focus on producing high-quality content to achieve long-term business results.

SEO. Something you vaguely remember dealing with, what was it, back in 2019? You're not alone in neglecting your site's search engine optimization. Yet, SEO is alive and kicking. It's just as important as ever. This website gets more than 80% of its traffic from Organic Searches. It's also easy to do poorly as never before. Throw everything into ChatGPT and be done? Have at it.

How to Fail at SEO - It is Easier Than You Think

With over 90% of all internet searches, Google rules the search world and upgrades that search with frequently updated algorithms to move the focus to different site areas to determine where it ranks on the search engine results page (SERP). As long as this is the case, SEO will remain a topic of much debate and, indeed, much utility for those who stay away from these surefire ways to fail at SEO.

By relying on the "one keyword per page" method

  • Long-tail keyword searches make up over 70% of all Google searches. People search for more specific queries and phrases rather than just one or two words.

  • Over 50% of searches are done on mobile devices, and voice search is becoming increasingly popular, with 55% of households having a smart speaker (in addition to yourself). As a result, we need to optimize content for longer, more conversational queries that people use when they speak and type into search engines.

People aren't searching for "brisket" anymore; they're searching for "brisket recipe with no ketchup" or "what's that meat dish my grandma made every spring?"

 True; there was a time when ranking for single keywords, like brisket, was the ultimate goal of SEO activities, and sites would cram their pages with those keywords. It wouldn't have been uncommon to find a single blog post with the word brisket repeated dozens of times. As a result of how off-putting this was to readers, Google adjusted their search to be more semantic and down-ranked sites that stuff keywords like that.

The way to rank now is about choosing the right keywords and including "keyword phrases" throughout your content naturally. So rather than trying to use the single keyword dozens of times, work on using them only as often as sounds natural, and include it in phrases people are using to search (which you can find by doing keyword research, of course). "Brisket recipes for spring," "How to make mouth-watering brisket in 5 easy steps," and the like.

How to Optimize Your Website for Modern SEO

Transform your outdated search practices into a modern, high-converting strategy by leveraging topic clusters and long-tail keywords. This workflow guides you through consolidating duplicate content, optimizing for semantic search, and establishing topical authority.

Effort: 1-2 weeks Tools Needed: 2
1
Target long-tail keyword phrases naturally

Shift away from single-keyword stuffing and focus on conversational, long-tail queries. Integrate these phrases naturally throughout your content to align with semantic and voice search trends.

2
Consolidate duplicate or overlapping content

Audit your site for multiple pages covering the exact same topic. Merge these redundant posts into a single, comprehensive long-form asset to avoid confusing search engines.

3
Group content into topic clusters

Organize your site architecture by linking related subtopics to a central pillar page. This structure builds topical authority and helps search engines understand your expertise.

4
Optimize every new page continuously

Treat SEO as an ongoing process rather than a one-time setup. Ensure every new landing page, blog post, or site update is fully optimized with appropriate links and CTAs.

5
Perform regular SEO and content audits

Implement a routine schedule to audit your website's search performance and content health. Use metrics to validate your strategy, track business results, and refine your approach over time.

Short on time or looking for deeper expertise?

Talk to our B2B consultants today

By forgetting the basics, like the fact that duplicate content is bad

Duplicate content on a site is not grounds for action on that site unless it appears that the intent of the duplicate content is to be deceptive and manipulate search engine results. If your site suffers from duplicate content issues, and you don’t follow the advice listed in this document, we do a good job of choosing a version of the content to show in our search results.     (Google)

There is one more scenario where duplicate content may pop up: on a site that's been languishing, unloved, for years. If you're tasked with bringing a decrepit corporate site back from the brink, content marketing is your method of choice.

Take the time to comb the site for pages that appear multiple times or blog posts that seem to have been posted more than once.

  • The five ways to rank on Google
  • 25 Benefits of Ranking in Search
  • How Search rankings can be beneficial to your business

Consolidate the above duplications into one long-form and meaningful contribution and keep improving it rather than writing another tweak to the same theme and publishing it as new. You confuse Google in its quest to select your best contribution and annoy your readers.

New call-to-action

By thinking that once you've "done" SEO, you're done

This is a biggie. There are unscrupulous hucksters out there selling fix-all solutions to your SEO woes. They may do a decent job optimizing your site as it exists on the day you run the program. But what happens next week? Or next month?

More on Search Engine Optimization HubSpot Partner Checklist for AI Search Visibility 2026

SEO done right can increase organic searchers and leads...if you nurture it and update your tactics to keep up with the ever-changing landscape.

Each new page you upload, be it a landing page for a special offer, a blog post, or even a redo on your careers page—should be optimized. When you have a cluster of posts that circle a pillar page on that topic, each page needs to be updated with the right links and CTAs, not only so your existing readers can navigate them but so new readers can find them in the first place. These so-called topic clusters are one of the newer additions to Google's algorithm. They increase people's trust in you and your content, increase the authority Google sees in your content, and finally increase their pull on your ranking.

By failing to see the big picture

Move from "ranking a post" to becoming a "topic authority":

  • Define Topic Clusters:  Grouping content around a central topic or pillar page, topic clusters create a more comprehensive and authoritative online presence that search engines like Google recognize and reward with higher search rankings. Topic clusters allow for targeting long-tail, lower-volume keywords, which can increase search traffic and engagement and help gain greater visibility.

  • Metrics matter: If your latest content marketing campaign works, having the data to back you up at your next shareholder meeting is always good. And conversely, if the campaign is failing, knowing ASAP so you can pull the plug will save time and money.

  • SEO is not only about ranking and SERP placement: It's about business results. It's about working together to achieve great things for your customers.

  • SEO is a long game: The changes you make this week may not have a visible impact on your bottom line for weeks or even months. That doesn't mean you stop doing it. It means you must remember and use those metrics to back up your successes.

  • Quality content is still your #1 asset in content marketing: You will reap SEO rewards over time by publishing it regularly and consistently and nurturing it via social media and other forms of propagation.

  • Perform regular Content/SEO Audits. Performing a frequent SEO Audit for your website should be a standard practice in your website operations; we perform daily SEO Audits for our site.

Ahrefs Site Audit rating

Building a solid SEO foundation matters more than ever to increase traffic and lead conversions. While the specifics, algorithms, and results have changed, the underlying fact remains that you need to pay attention to your site's SEO to rank and be selected by AI to be presented as "the one answer."

Don't forget the basics, don't become complacent and neglect your existing pages, and don't fall into any other traps discussed above, and you'll be off to a great start!

Curious About SEO?  Use the Right Tools to Grow Your Business!

You Might Also Like